A Jain Gujarati live gathiya nu shaak with hing tadka and buttermilk gravy. Press homemade gathiya into the boiling kadhai. No onion, garlic, or ginger.
1cupbuttermilk (chaas)or 1/2 cup yogurt whisked with 1/2 cup water, room temperature
1cupwaterplus more as needed
1tablespoonKashmiri red chilli powderuse 2 tablespoons for extra color
1/2teaspoonturmeric powder
1tablespooncumin-coriander powder (dhana-jeeru)
1teaspoonjaggery powderor a small pinch of sugar
saltto taste
For the tadka
2tablespoonsoilor ghee
1/2teaspoonmustard seeds
1/2teaspooncumin seeds
pinchasafoetida (hing)
2dried red chillieswhole
8-10curry leavesoptional
1-2green chilliescrushed to a paste, omit for strict Paryushan
To finish
2tablespoonscoriander leaveschopped, optional
Get Recipe Ingredients
Instructions
Make the gathiya dough
In a bowl, mix besan, red chilli powder, turmeric, ajwain, hing, salt, and 1 teaspoon oil. Add water a spoon at a time until you have a soft, slightly sticky dough that will pass through a sev maker or slotted spoon. If it is stiff, add a little more water. If it is runny, add a spoon of besan. Load a sev maker with a gathiya or thick-sev disc.
Make the tadka
Heat oil or ghee in a kadhai over medium. Add mustard seeds. When they pop, add cumin seeds, hing, dried red chillies, curry leaves if using, and the green chilli paste. Let them sizzle 20 to 30 seconds until the hing smells toasted, not raw.
Cook the gravy
Lower the flame. Stir in Kashmiri chilli, turmeric, and cumin-coriander powder. Mix for 10 to 15 seconds so the masala does not burn.
Pour in the buttermilk and 1 cup water while stirring. Add salt and jaggery. Bring to a gentle boil, stirring so the chaas does not split. The gravy has to be simmering before the gathiya goes in.
Press the live gathiya
Hold the sev maker over the kadhai and press the dough directly into the boiling gravy. Keep moving so the strands do not pile up and stick. If you are using a slotted spoon, set a handful of dough on it and press through with your fingers, moving around the pan.
Do not stir for 1 to 2 minutes so the gathiya sets. Then cover and cook on medium-low for 7 to 8 minutes, until the gathiya is soft and cooked through. If the gravy thickens too much, add a splash of hot water.
Taste for salt, chilli, and jaggery. Garnish with coriander if your kitchen uses it. Serve immediately with roti, thepla, bajra rotla, or rice.
Notes
The gravy must be boiling when you press the dough. If it is only warm, the gathiya melts into lumps.Room-temperature chaas, and stirring as it comes to a boil, is what keeps this from splitting.Live gathiya is meant to be soft and soaked. This is not the fried-gathiya-at-the-table version.Leftovers do not keep well. The gathiya drinks the gravy in the fridge. Make only what you will eat.For gluten-free, use a wheat-free hing. Many compound hing blends contain wheat.No sev maker: a slotted spoon works. Press a little dough at a time and keep the spoon moving.